Discussion:
MY FAVE TOP 20 BY A VOCAL GROUP.......1954
Add Reply
Roger
2024-11-03 07:53:30 UTC
Reply
Permalink
MY FAVE 20 RECORDS BY A VOCAL GROUP

TODAY........FROM 1954

1. WORK WITH ME ANNIE – THE ROYALS (MIDNIGHTERS)


At last here’s the big one for the Royals group who have graced the r&b
scene with some splendid records over the past couple of years including
“Every Beat Of My Heart”,”Moonrise” etc all done for the Federal label.
“Work With Me Annie” is the real big one going to #1 on the BB r&b chart
but undergoing a major change in the group’s name halfway thru this
record’s run---when they become the more familiar The Midnighters!

2. ANNIE HAD A BABY – THE MIDNIGHTERS


How do you follow a record like “Work With Me Annie”? There’s always the
oft tried and usually tested sequel song route which in this case yields
the predictable-but excellent-“Annie Had A Baby” which will also turn
out to be both great to listen to—but will also return the Federal
group back to #1 BB r&b with this classic followup.The song appeared on
a 78 only UK pressing on Parlophone (b/w "Sexy Ways")--but which was
made for export overseas only. I have NEVER seen a copy
https://www.45worlds.com/78rpm/record/dp399

3. EARTH ANGEL (WILL YOU BE MINE) – THE PENGUINS


We’re about to do a roll call of some of the most famous and certainly
most legendary of 1950’s r&b vocal group recordings so fasten your seat
belts! What better place to start than with L.A.’s own The Penguins (led
by Cleve Duncan) with their trademark anthem “Earth Angel” recorded for
Dootsie Williams’ Dootone label. Charted at #8 BB pop and #1 BB r&b.
Released in UK on London and is one of the very rarest of the rare
British releases of the 50's

4. GLORIA – THE CADILLACS


Glorious “Gloria”! One of the greatest ever debuts in the vocal group
side of rock ‘n’ roll history as The Cadillacs make their first
appearance on record on the Josie label with a revival of the beautiful
ballad first recorded back in 1946 by Bob Hayward. Did not chart and no
UK release

5. THE WIND – THE DIABLOS


Time to hear from dazzling Detroit now as the city’s finest The Diablos
fronted by Nolan Strong step forward with their best record (IMO) the
wonderful “The Wind” on the Fortune label (a song picked up later in a
good version by NYC’s The Jesters recorded partly because of increased
interest in the song later on in east coast locations

6. YOUR CASH AIN’T NOTHIN’ BUT TRASH – THE CLOVERS


Recorded in NYC April 16 1954 at the session for Atlantic that also
produced “In The Morning Time” and the unissued “Nobody But You”. “Your
Cash Ain’t Nothin’ But Trash” became their second single of 1954
following “Lovey Dovey” Charted at #6 BB r&b.. Released in UK as
Atlantic single---but not till 1968 (!)

7. SINCERELY – THE MOONGLOWS


Here’s the song that Alan Freed sat up all night co-writing—The
Moonglows’ first record for the Chess label with a splendid lead by
Bobby Lester. It reached #1 on BB r&b chart spawning a very successful
pop cover by The McGuire Sisters (#1 in BB). We only got one version
here in UK (no prizes for guessing which)

8. GOODNITE SWEETHEART GOODNITE – THE SPANIELS


One of the most famous “sign off” songs of all was recorded for Vee Jay
September 23 1953 and released in March 1954.A good seller for them it
reached #5 BB r&b Again it was covered by dem same damn McGuire Sisters
who again got the big pop hit.This time neither version was issued in UK

9. BABY I NEED YOU – THE EL DORADOS


Enter the El Darados as ultra-rare original copies have it (later
pressings switched to the name in the header here). Again these guys
were signed to Vee Jay in Chicago and this was their debut record. This
didn’t chart (they’d have to wait till 1955 and “At My Front Door” for
that). This group NEVER had a UK single released

10. WHITE CHRISTMAS – THE DRIFTERS


Not the first version of the Christmas perennial by a blues group (that
honor goes to the Ravens in 1948). Recorded February 4 1954 the Irving
Berlin Christmas anthem ---popularized by Der Bingle of course---in this
Drifters version for Atlantic utilized both Clyde McPhatter and Bill
Pinkney as shared lead. The record charted multiple times (in various
years) on both BB charts peaking at #80 (in 1955 pop) and #2 (1954
r&b). No UK release

11. RIOT IN CELL BLOCK #9 – THE ROBINS


Not only one of The Robins best but also one of Leiber & Stoller’s best
numbers too and was the first release by the group on L&S‘s own Spark
record label. Because of the pretty vivid storyline the record found
itself banned on quite a few radio stations which surely affected sales
as it didn’t chart. Not released UK

12. I LIKE IT LIKE THAT – THE “5” ROYALES


Backed by Charlie “Little Jazz” Ferguson & his band this “highly
rhythmic effort” on the Apollo label as Billboard termed it in their
review is to my mind one of the best things the Royales ever did and
certainly one of my top favorites by them. Sadly in spite of all it had
going for it the record failed to chart

13. HEARTS OF STONE – THE JEWELS


Led by Johnny Torrence here are five man Jewels outfit from Los Angeles
with their splendid original version of the much recorded “Hearts Of
Stone” song on the small R&B label. Most of the r&b sales on the song
went to the Otis Williams and his group The Charms (see below) who took
their cover version to #1 BB r&b whilst the pop sales were dominated by
the million selling Fontane Sisters version which made #1 on the BB pop
chart. There were a LOT of other versions too but I’ll stick with dem
glittering Jewels

14. SH-BOOM – THE CHORDS


Another original version here and another that spawned a whole raft of
cover versions.This time our heroes come from the Bronx with one of the
earliest real true anthems of rock ‘n’ roll that again spawned a myriad
of cover versions. Signed by Atlantic their first record “Sh-Boom”
appeared on their new subsid Cat label and promptly started selling big
even crossing over to the BB pop charts where it made #5 (and #2 BB r&b)
followed by other covers including The Crew Cuts #1 pop hit and a very
humorous comedy version by Stan Freberg (#14 BB pop)

15. WOMEN AND CADILLACS – THE NITE RIDERS


Led by “Doc” Starkes The Nite Riders enjoyed a fairly lengthy career
(right into the 60’s) starting off with the rocking “Women And
Cadillacs” recorded for the Apollo label. Cash Box in their review
called it “a quick beat r&b cutie”. As with so many vocal group items
from this era this was booted big time in the 1970’s

16. SEXY WAYS – THE MIDNIGHTERS


The immediate followup to “Work With Me Annie” (and BEFORE “Annie Had A
Baby”) on Federal which explains the notice “Formerly The Royals” under
the artist credit on the record label. A good seller for the boys it sat
at #2 on the BB r&b chart. See entry #2 above re UK release

17. BIP BAM – THE DRIFTERS


With a rockin’ Clyde McPhatter lead The Drifters show up again here with
“Bip Bam” recorded November 12 1953 at a session that also produced
"Don’t Dog Me”,”Such A Night” and “Warm Your Heart”. Released in October
1954 the Atlantic release coupled With “Someday You’ll Want Me To Want
You” scored a #7 hit BB r&b

18. HEARTS OF STONE – THE CHARMS


Tho I prefer the Jewels original version (see above) The Charms cover
for DeLuxe was certainly THE big version in the r&b market where it
spent NINE weeks at #1 in Billboard and even crossed over to their main
pop chart (#15 there). Amazingly this managed to get a UK release—but
not until well into 1955 where---coupled with “Ko Ko Mo”---it appeared
on the Parlophone label

19. WRAP IT UP – THE ROBINS


The Robins score again here with the Carl Gardner-led “Wrap It Up”
another Leiber & Stoller anthem for their Spark label and released as
the flipside to the famous “Riot In Cell Block #9” (see above)

20. I USED TO CRY MERCY MERCY – THE LAMPLIGHTERS


A cracking Rudolph Toombs number here for The Lamplighters with their
fourth release on Federal. A strong four man outfit featuring future
hitmaker one Thurston Harris,they should really have been much bigger
than they were. Good sellers on the West Coast but not many other places
apparently.

BUBBLING UNDER

21. LOVE’S ALL I’M PUTTIN’ DOWN – THE SPIDERS (UNRELEASED)
22. LET’S MAKE UP – THE SPANIELS
23. GOD ONLY KNOWS – THE CAPRIS
24. FRAMED – THE ROBINS
25. MARY LEE – THE RAINBOWS
Bruce
2024-11-03 20:32:05 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Roger
MY FAVE 20 RECORDS BY A VOCAL GROUP
15. WOMEN AND CADILLACS – THE NITE RIDERS
http://youtu.be/2qDAuQb8N6w
And here is a perfect example of how caring about names of groups and
what record labels say gets you in trouble. There is only one voice on
this record. There is no possible way that it can be classified as a
vocal group record.
Bruce
2024-11-03 20:34:34 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Here is what I have for 1954:

MY TOP VOCAL GROUP RECORDINGS FROM 1954:
1 ¦ Baby I Need You ¦ El Dorados
2 ¦ I Was Wrong ¦ Moonglows
3 ¦ Annie Had A Baby ¦ Midnighters
4 ¦ My Lovin' Baby ¦ El Dorados
5 ¦ Wrap It Up ¦ Robins
6 ¦ You Ain't Ready ¦ Flamingos
7 ¦ Love's All I'm Puttin' Down ¦ Spiders
8 ¦ Ling Ting Tong ¦ Five Keys
9 ¦ The Wind ¦ Diablos
10 ¦ Work With Me Annie ¦ Royals
11 ¦ Let's Make Up ¦ Spaniels
12 ¦ I'm Slippin' In ¦ Spiders
13 ¦ I Used To Cry Mercy Mercy ¦ Lamplighters
14 ¦ Sincerely ¦ Moonglows
15 ¦ Hearts Of Stone ¦ Jewels
16 ¦ Buick 59 ¦ Medallions
17 ¦ Riot In Cell Block # 9 ¦ Robins
18 ¦ Gloria ¦ Cadillacs
19 ¦ Hearts Of Stone ¦ Charms
20 ¦ God Only Knows ¦ Capris
21 ¦ Real Gone Mama ¦ Moonglows
22 ¦ Give It Up ¦ Midnighters
23 ¦ 219 Train ¦ Moonglows
24 ¦ Earth Angel ¦ Penguins
25 ¦ Jump Children ¦ Flamingos
26 ¦ Sh-Boom ¦ Chords
27 ¦ Tweedle Dee ¦ LaVern Baker
28 ¦ White Christmas ¦ Drifters
29 ¦ Don't Stop Dan ¦ Checkers
30 ¦ Honey Love ¦ Drifters
31 ¦ You've Been Fooling Around ¦ Checkers
32 ¦ Sexy Ways ¦ Midnighters
33 ¦ Hey Senorita ¦ Penguins
34 ¦ Warm Your Heart ¦ Drifters
35 ¦ Goodnite, Sweetheart, Goodnite ¦ Spaniels
36 ¦ I Wanna Know ¦ Lamplighters
37 ¦ Your Cash Ain't Nothing But Trash ¦ Clovers
38 ¦ My Baby Dearest Darling ¦ Charms
39 ¦ Ookey Ook ¦ Penguins
40 ¦ Lovey Dovey ¦ Clovers
41 ¦ Rice, Red Beans And Turnip Greens ¦ Tempo-Toppers (Little Richard)
42 ¦ Crazy Loving (Stay With Me) ¦ Midnighters
43 ¦ Framed ¦ Robins
44 ¦ Blue Valentine ¦ Solitaires
45 ¦ Play It Cool ¦ Spaniels
46 ¦ Sister Lucy ¦ Bobby Mitchell & Toppers
47 ¦ Tears Began To Flow ¦ Spiders
48 ¦ Annie's Answer ¦ Hazel McCollum and El Dorados
49 ¦ Bip Bam ¦ Drifters
50 ¦ My Gal ¦ Moonglows
51 ¦ Blues In A Letter ¦ Flamingos
52 ¦ It Was Just For Laughs ¦ Harptones
53 ¦ Oh Yes I Know ¦ Jewels
54 ¦ My Memories Of You ¦ Harptones
55 ¦ Mellow As A Man Can Be ¦ Hollywood Flames (unissued master)
56 ¦ Lonesome Desert ¦ Young Jessie (Flairs)
57 ¦ Deep In My Heart ¦ Five Keys
58 ¦ Little Mama ¦ Clovers
59 ¦ Mercy Me ¦ Lil Greenwood & Lamplighters
60 ¦ Plan For Love ¦ Flamingos
61 ¦ 333 ¦ Drifters
62 ¦ Dig That Crazy Santa Claus ¦ Oscar McLollie
63 ¦ Mmm Mmm Baby ¦ Spiders
64 ¦ Real Humdinger ¦ Five Pearls
65 ¦ Loop De Loop Mambo ¦ Robins
66 ¦ Lucille ¦ Drifters
67 ¦ Sneakin' Around ¦ B.B. King
68 ¦ Untrue ¦ Crows
69 ¦ Smoke From Your Cigarette ¦ Mellows
70 ¦ Secret Love ¦ Moonglows
71 ¦ Mellow Mama ¦ Spiders
72 ¦ Wailin' Little Mama ¦ Counts
73 ¦ I Confess ¦ Clovers
74 ¦ House With No Windows ¦ Checkers
75 ¦ All Righty Oh Sweetie ¦ Clovers
76 ¦ Going Home ¦ Jimmy Ricks (Ravens)
77 ¦ Over A Cup of Coffee ¦ Castelles
78 ¦ Johnny Darling ¦ Feathers
79 ¦ Stingy Little Thing ¦ Midnighters
80 ¦ Such A Night ¦ Drifters
81 ¦ Bye Bye Young Men ¦ Ruth Brown
82 ¦ I've Got My Eyes On You ¦ Clovers
83 ¦ Mary Lee ¦ Rainbows
84 ¦ I Wonder Why ¦ Cadillacs
85 ¦ Daddy Daddy ¦ Richard Berry & Dreamers
86 ¦ I'm Stuck ¦ Five Jets
87 ¦ Love Me Girl ¦ Flairs
88 ¦ I Like It Like That ¦ Five Royales
89 ¦ Oop Shoop ¦ Shirley Gunter & Queens
90 ¦ Forget It ¦ Larks
91 ¦ I Do ¦ Five Royales
92 ¦ Fine Fine Girl ¦ Moonglows
93 ¦ Somebody Touched Me ¦ Ruth Brown
94 ¦ Key To My Heart ¦ Robins
95 ¦ Ooh Rocking Daddy ¦ Moonglows
96 ¦ Monkey Hips and Rice ¦ Five Royales
97 ¦ I Long For You ¦ Five C's
98 ¦ Don't Blooper ¦ Grady Chapman & Suedes
99 ¦ Hot Tamales ¦ Counts
100 ¦ Fifty Five Seconds ¦ Charms
101 ¦ Oo-Ee Baby ¦ Lloyd Price
102 ¦ I'm A Young Man ¦ Bobby Mitchell & Toppers
103 ¦ Beg and Steal ¦ Strangers
104 ¦ Talk About The Weather ¦ Gems
105 ¦ She Keeps Me Wondering ¦ Spiders
106 ¦ Someday You'll Want Me To Want You ¦ Drifters
107 ¦ She's The One ¦ Midnighters
108 ¦ Darling Dear ¦ Counts
109 ¦ Please Remember My Heart ¦ Solitaires
110 ¦ Baby's Gone ¦ Bobby Mitchell & Toppers
111 ¦ The Bells of St Mary's ¦ Drifters
112 ¦ Let Me Come Back Home ¦ Five Royales
113 ¦ Gettin' High ¦ Flairs
114 ¦ Baby Wants ¦ Flairs
115 ¦ What You Do To Me ¦ Richard Berry
116 ¦ Let's Make with Some Love ¦ Flairs
117 ¦ Dead Broke ¦ Du Droppers
118 ¦ I Wasn't Thinking, I Was Drinking ¦ Checkers
119 ¦ Shoo Doo Be Doo (My Loving Baby) ¦ Bobby Lester & Moonlighters
120 ¦ Oh But She Did ¦ Opals
121 ¦ No There Ain't No News Today ¦ Penguins
122 ¦ Blue Flowers ¦ Strangers
123 ¦ Lawdy Lawdy Miss Mary ¦ Five Keys
124 ¦ Ain't Nothing Wrong With That ¦ Shufflers
125 ¦ Listen To My Plea ¦ Flamingos
126 ¦ All Women Are The Same ¦ Hawks
127 ¦ He's The Fat Man ¦ Hawks
128 ¦ Mama's Daughter ¦ Checkers
129 ¦ Soup Line ¦ Leon Tarver & Chordones
130 ¦ Bluesy Me ¦ Dave Collins & Scrubs
131 ¦ A Fool in Paradise ¦ Jewels
132 ¦ Nobody But Me ¦ Hawks
133 ¦ Ain't Gonna Do It ¦ Pelicans
134 ¦ It Won't Take Long (alternate) ¦ Native Boys
135 ¦ Please Please Baby ¦ Five Hearts
136 ¦ Baby Let's Play House ¦ Thunderbirds
137 ¦ That Woman ¦ Midnighters
138 ¦ Got Ta Feed The Ol' Horse Lotta Hay ¦ Volumes
139 ¦ School Girl ¦ Five Royales
140 ¦ Every Day ¦ Peacheroos
141 ¦ I'm Gonna Move To The Outskirts of Town ¦ Dominoes
142 ¦ Big Wig Walk ¦ Marbles
143 ¦ Bazoom (I Need Your Lovin') ¦ Cheers
144 ¦ You Gotta Be Good To Yourself ¦ Dolly Cooper (Wanderers)
145 ¦ Rainbow Of Love ¦ Cherokees
146 ¦ Love Will Make Your Mind Go Wild ¦ Penguins
147 ¦ The Letter ¦ Medallions
148 ¦ Wishing Well ¦ Cadillacs
149 ¦ Baby Come A Little Bit Closer ¦ Five Willows
150 ¦ Lizabeth ¦ Thrillers
Roger
2024-11-04 07:50:56 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Here's the vocal group records from here that made my Top 200 1954 list
Post by Bruce
1 ¦ Baby I Need You ¦ El Dorados
#28 - 9
Post by Bruce
2 ¦ I Was Wrong ¦ Moonglows
#76 - 8
Post by Bruce
3 ¦ Annie Had A Baby ¦ Midnighters
#8 - 10
Post by Bruce
5 ¦ Wrap It Up ¦ Robins
#39 - 9
Post by Bruce
7 ¦ Love's All I'm Puttin' Down ¦ Spiders
#41 - 9
Post by Bruce
8 ¦ Ling Ting Tong ¦ Five Keys
#145 - 8
Post by Bruce
9 ¦ The Wind ¦ Diablos
#14 - 10
Post by Bruce
10 ¦ Work With Me Annie ¦ Royals
#7 - 10
Post by Bruce
11 ¦ Let's Make Up ¦ Spaniels
#45 - 9
Post by Bruce
12 ¦ I'm Slippin' In ¦ Spiders
#80 - 8
Post by Bruce
13 ¦ I Used To Cry Mercy Mercy ¦ Lamplighters
#40 - 9
Post by Bruce
14 ¦ Sincerely ¦ Moonglows
#19 - 10
Post by Bruce
15 ¦ Hearts Of Stone ¦ Jewels
#32 - 9
Post by Bruce
16 ¦ Buick 59 ¦ Medallions
#81 - 8
Post by Bruce
17 ¦ Riot In Cell Block # 9 ¦ Robins
#30 - 9
Post by Bruce
18 ¦ Gloria ¦ Cadillacs
#10 - 10
Post by Bruce
19 ¦ Hearts Of Stone ¦ Charms
#38 - 9
Post by Bruce
20 ¦ God Only Knows ¦ Capris
#51 - 9
Post by Bruce
21 ¦ Real Gone Mama ¦ Moonglows
#146 - 8
Post by Bruce
22 ¦ Give It Up ¦ Midnighters
#100 - 8
Post by Bruce
23 ¦ 219 Train ¦ Moonglows
#149 - 8
Post by Bruce
24 ¦ Earth Angel ¦ Penguins
#9 - 10
Post by Bruce
25 ¦ Jump Children ¦ Flamingos
#154 - 8
Post by Bruce
26 ¦ Sh-Boom ¦ Chords
#33 - 9
Post by Bruce
28 ¦ White Christmas ¦ Drifters
#29 - 9
Post by Bruce
29 ¦ Don't Stop Dan ¦ Checkers
#163 - 8
Post by Bruce
30 ¦ Honey Love ¦ Drifters
#148 - 8
Post by Bruce
32 ¦ Sexy Ways ¦ Midnighters
#36 - 9
Post by Bruce
33 ¦ Hey Senorita ¦ Penguins
#111 - 8
Post by Bruce
34 ¦ Warm Your Heart ¦ Drifters
#110 - 8
Post by Bruce
35 ¦ Goodnite, Sweetheart, Goodnite ¦ Spaniels
#20 - 10
Post by Bruce
36 ¦ I Wanna Know ¦ Lamplighters
#77 - 8
Post by Bruce
37 ¦ Your Cash Ain't Nothing But Trash ¦ Clovers
#18 - 10
Post by Bruce
40 ¦ Lovey Dovey ¦ Clovers
#147 - 8
Post by Bruce
43 ¦ Framed ¦ Robins
#66 - 8
Post by Bruce
45 ¦ Play It Cool ¦ Spaniels
#90 - 8
Post by Bruce
46 ¦ Sister Lucy ¦ Bobby Mitchell & Toppers
#116 - 8
Post by Bruce
48 ¦ Annie's Answer ¦ Hazel McCollum and El Dorados
#129 - 8
Post by Bruce
49 ¦ Bip Bam ¦ Drifters
#37 -9
Post by Bruce
57 ¦ Deep In My Heart ¦ Five Keys
#187 - 8
Post by Bruce
58 ¦ Little Mama ¦ Clovers
#109 - 8
Post by Bruce
61 ¦ 333 ¦ Drifters
#159 - 8
Post by Bruce
64 ¦ Real Humdinger ¦ Five Pearls
#135 - 8
Post by Bruce
65 ¦ Loop De Loop Mambo ¦ Robins
#117 – 8
Post by Bruce
66 ¦ Lucille ¦ Drifters
#75 – 8
Post by Bruce
69 ¦ Smoke From Your Cigarette ¦ Mellows
I show this in 1955
Post by Bruce
77 ¦ Over A Cup of Coffee ¦ Castelles
#101 - 8
Post by Bruce
82 ¦ I've Got My Eyes On You ¦ Clovers
#198 – 8
Post by Bruce
83 ¦ Mary Lee ¦ Rainbows
#67 - 8
Post by Bruce
88 ¦ I Like It Like That ¦ Five Royales
#31 - 9
Post by Bruce
95 ¦ Ooh Rocking Daddy ¦ Moonglows
#179 - 8
Post by Bruce
99 ¦ Hot Tamales ¦ Counts
#139 - 8
Post by Bruce
102 ¦ I'm A Young Man ¦ Bobby Mitchell & Toppers
#184 - 8
Post by Bruce
109 ¦ Please Remember My Heart ¦ Solitaires
#69 - 8
Post by Bruce
120 ¦ Oh But She Did ¦ Opals
#157 – 8
Post by Bruce
127 ¦ He's The Fat Man ¦ Hawks
#153 - 8
Post by Bruce
148 ¦ Wishing Well ¦ Cadillacs
#171 – 8

Roger
2024-11-03 21:04:54 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
MY FAVE 20 RECORDS BY A VOCAL GROUP
15. WOMEN AND CADILLACS – THE NITE RIDERS
http://youtu.be/2qDAuQb8N6w
And here is a perfect example of how caring about names of groups and
what record labels say gets you in trouble. There is only one voice on
this record. There is no possible way that it can be classified as a
vocal group record.
Really?? I honestly never heard that before. Okay I accept what you say
and we're even for that Gene Pitney thing (hey did I ever mention here
that I once took.....gee I must have done!).

Take out the Nite Riders,move everything below it up one notch and make
the new #25 "Get With It" - The Flamingos
Bruce
2024-11-03 21:18:12 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Roger
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
MY FAVE 20 RECORDS BY A VOCAL GROUP
15. WOMEN AND CADILLACS – THE NITE RIDERS
http://youtu.be/2qDAuQb8N6w
And here is a perfect example of how caring about names of groups and
what record labels say gets you in trouble. There is only one voice on
this record. There is no possible way that it can be classified as a
vocal group record.
Really?? I honestly never heard that before. Okay I accept what you say
and we're even for that Gene Pitney thing
No, I still say that "Love My Life Away" is a vocal group record. Who is
singing the rest of the vocal parts is not relevant to whether or not
it's a vocal group record.

Same as the Blue Sky Boys and "The Longest Time" by Billy Joel.
Otherwise you better contact Kreiter and tell him that he has a lot of
records listed in his "Vocal Group Record Guide" that are no vocal group
records.

Like this one from Steve Propes' favorite vocal group.


Roger
2024-11-03 21:55:51 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
MY FAVE 20 RECORDS BY A VOCAL GROUP
15. WOMEN AND CADILLACS – THE NITE RIDERS
http://youtu.be/2qDAuQb8N6w
And here is a perfect example of how caring about names of groups and
what record labels say gets you in trouble. There is only one voice on
this record. There is no possible way that it can be classified as a
vocal group record.
Really?? I honestly never heard that before. Okay I accept what you say
and we're even for that Gene Pitney thing
No, I still say that "Love My Life Away" is a vocal group record. Who is
singing the rest of the vocal parts is not relevant to whether or not
it's a vocal group record.
Same as the Blue Sky Boys and "The Longest Time" by Billy Joel.
Otherwise you better contact Kreiter and tell him that he has a lot of
records listed in his "Vocal Group Record Guide" that are no vocal group
records.
Like this one from Steve Propes' favorite vocal group.
http://youtu.be/q8j-px3fojw
There is NO WAY that a record with just ONE person multi-tracked singing
is a vocal group record and Kreiter can go jump in a lake
Bruce
2024-11-03 22:47:07 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Roger
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
MY FAVE 20 RECORDS BY A VOCAL GROUP
15. WOMEN AND CADILLACS – THE NITE RIDERS
http://youtu.be/2qDAuQb8N6w
And here is a perfect example of how caring about names of groups and
what record labels say gets you in trouble. There is only one voice on
this record. There is no possible way that it can be classified as a
vocal group record.
Really?? I honestly never heard that before. Okay I accept what you say
and we're even for that Gene Pitney thing
No, I still say that "Love My Life Away" is a vocal group record. Who is
singing the rest of the vocal parts is not relevant to whether or not
it's a vocal group record.
Same as the Blue Sky Boys and "The Longest Time" by Billy Joel.
Otherwise you better contact Kreiter and tell him that he has a lot of
records listed in his "Vocal Group Record Guide" that are no vocal group
records.
Like this one from Steve Propes' favorite vocal group.
http://youtu.be/q8j-px3fojw
There is NO WAY that a record with just ONE person multi-tracked singing
is a vocal group record and Kreiter can go jump in a lake
Should Propes jump in too?
Bruce
2024-11-03 23:11:36 UTC
Reply
Permalink
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
Post by Bruce
Post by Roger
MY FAVE 20 RECORDS BY A VOCAL GROUP
15. WOMEN AND CADILLACS – THE NITE RIDERS
http://youtu.be/2qDAuQb8N6w
And here is a perfect example of how caring about names of groups and
what record labels say gets you in trouble. There is only one voice on
this record. There is no possible way that it can be classified as a
vocal group record.
Really?? I honestly never heard that before. Okay I accept what you say
and we're even for that Gene Pitney thing
No, I still say that "Love My Life Away" is a vocal group record. Who is
singing the rest of the vocal parts is not relevant to whether or not
it's a vocal group record.
Same as the Blue Sky Boys and "The Longest Time" by Billy Joel.
Otherwise you better contact Kreiter and tell him that he has a lot of
records listed in his "Vocal Group Record Guide" that are no vocal group
records.
Like this one from Steve Propes' favorite vocal group.
http://youtu.be/q8j-px3fojw
There is NO WAY that a record with just ONE person multi-tracked singing
is a vocal group record and Kreiter can go jump in a lake
Should Propes jump in too?
What about the tons of recordings where one person plays more than one
instrument on the same recording. If a band like the Beatles makes a
record where Paul plays more than one instrument (like bass and
keyboards), does that mean that the it's no longer a record by a band?

The only Beatle who plays on "Yesterday" is Paul. Does that mean that
it's not a Beatles record?

The only Beatle who plays on "Within You, Without You" is George. Does
that mean that it's not a Beatles record?

Only John and Paul play on "The Ballad of John And Yoko." George and
Paul were on holiday and John wanted to record it right away. So Paul
played the drums and they overdubbed other parts too. Does that mean
that it's not a Beatles record?

On "Back In The USSR" Paul plays the drums as well as the bass as Ringo
had quit the band for a few days at that time. Does that mean that this
track is not a Beatles record?

If one person is allowed to overdub an instrument on a recording, why
can't they also overdub a voice or even all of the voices on a
recording?

There are plenty of records where the lead also overdubs background
vocals.
Loading...